Socio-demographic and Clinical Characteristic of Women Availing Pap Smear Services in Samtse District, Bhutan
Background: The case burden of cervical cancer has been increasing globally especially in developing countries without proper health system. Cervical cancer can be eliminated with timely vaccination and screening program as it usually takes years for pre-malignant lesions to develop into malignant lesion. Bhutan has committed to eliminate cervical cancer. Thus, it is important to understand the factors associated with abnormal Pap test findings.
Methodology: A retrospective study was conducted using the Pap smear data for the year 2018. It was extracted from the records maintained in the cytology unit of Samtse General Hospital.
Result: The abnormal slide rate in this study was 2.5%. The majority of women seeking Pap smear services were women in reproductive age group and housewife by occupation. There were significant differences between age groups and marital status among normal in the Pap test results.
Conclusion: The slide abnormality of Pap smear in Samtse District is low. The abnormality is more common among married and older women. Therefore, additional screening efforts needs to be put into this group to detect pre-malignant lesions.
Cervical cancer is the fourth most common cancer affecting women. In 2018, at least 0.57 million cases of cervical cancer were diagnosed globally accounting for 6.6% of all cancers among women  and 7.5% of total deaths from cancer among females . The majority (90%) of the deaths occurred in low- and middle-income countries [3-4]. The South East Asian Region alone contributes to about 35% of the global burden of the disease .
Unlike other types of cancers, cervical cancer is usually preventable with vaccination. Moreover, patients tend to have high survival rate if diagnosed and treated at early stages. There are mainly two types of cervical cancer. The squamous cell carcinoma constitutes around 70% of the cases and adenocarcinoma constitutes 20% of all cervical cancer . An estimated 99-100% of the cervical cancers are attributed to Human Papilloma virus (HPV) infection with, HPV 16 and HPV18 alone accounting for almost 70% of the cervical cancers .
Nonetheless, 90% of the infection with HPV tend to be transient and doesn’t cause any dysplasia. Since the virus is transmitted through sexual route, women with multiple sexual partners, early sexual activity and multiple pregnancies are at higher risk for developing cervical cancer . Cervical cancer takes around 10-20 years to develop from pre-cancerous to cancerous stage . Therefore, timely screening and treatment helps in detection of this pre-cancerous lesions before it progresses to malignancy. Currently, WHO recommends three different types of screening test for cervical cancer. These include HPV testing, visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) , conventional Papanicolaou (Pap) smear or liquid based cytology . The main stay of screening for cervical cancer in most developing countries is Pap smear, although it has sensitivity of only 55.4% and specificity of 96.8% .
In developed countries with well-established screening and treating programs, the incidence of cervical cancer has decreased by almost 80% . The American Cancer Society and American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) guideline recommends Pap smear screening from 21 years of age regardless of sexual activity, repeated every three years thereafter. In addition, HPV testing should also be carried out along with Pap smear every five years for women in the ages of 30-65. However, annual screening is recommended for immunocompromised patients or those with history of pre-malignant or malignant lesions .
In Bhutan, cervical cancer is the most common cancer among women . Annually , an estimated 48 cases of cervical cancer are diagnosed in Bhutan with around 32 deaths . Cervical cancer accounted for 7.2% of the total 1,357 cancer cases in 2017 . The age standardized incidence of cervical cancer for Bhutan is 14.4 per 100,000 and age standardized mortality rate is 10.2 per 10,000 .
In Bhutan, the quadrivalent HPV vaccination was first introduced in 2010 and became the first nation in the region to have implemented population based HPV vaccination . Currently, HPV vaccination has been incorporated in the national immunization program and is given to all girls between ages of 9-13 years before the start of the sexual activity. Bhutan has committed for elimination of cervical cancers. The main strategy is through early detection and treatment of pre-cancerous lesion. Pap smear screening is one of the most organized and successful programs and is provided free by the government. It is carried out at all tiers of the health system ranging from basic health unit to referral hospitals. The National cancer screening manual of Bhutan recommends screening for all women in the age of 25-65 irrespective of vaccination status and repeated every three years if normal .
Samtse district is one of the largest districts located in the South west of Bhutan. It borders the Indian state of West Bengal. It has an estimated population of 62,590 . There are two hospitals, two BHU-1 and 13 basic health units. Samtse General Hospital has a cyto-technician and a gynecologist where cryotherapy and LEEP services are offered. The Pap smear is collected by a trained female health assistant in the maternal and child health unit. The smear is collected using Ayre’s spatula and spray fixed (prepared using 5ml polyethylene glycol and 200 ml 95% alcohol). The slides are sent to the Samtse hospital where the cytology-technicians screen for any abnormal or pre-malignant cells. The classification of Pap smear is done according to Bethesda classification system. The slides suspected to have abnormal cells or malignancies are sent to Referral Hospitals for further confirmation by the pathologist. The patients with low grade malignancy undergo colposcopy and Loop Electrosurgical Excision Procedure (LEEP) in centers with gynecologists.
There are scarce data on Pap smear in Bhutan due to paucity of research on this subject. Except for few studies on knowledge, attitude and practice on Pap smear and factors associated with opting out for screening, there are no studies conducted to estimate the abnormality of Pap smear. The study objective was conducted to estimate the abnormal slide rate and identify the factors associated with abnormal Pap smear in Samtse Dzongkhag.
Materials and Methods
Study design and setting
This was a retrospective cross-sectional study involving review of medical records maintained in the cytology unit of Samtse General Hospital.
All women who had received Pap screening services in BHUs and hospitals of Samtse District in the year 2018 were included in this study.
Data Sources and collection
The data was initially extracted from the Pap smear request form to pro-forma and later entered into epi data.
The variables used to check for associations were age of women, age at marriage, age at first pregnancy, number of sexual partners, number of children, history of sexually transmitted diseases and presence of symptoms.
The dependent variables were divided into normal Pap smear (examination of the smear slide was normal) and abnormal smear (Abnormal cells such as ASCUS, LSIL, HSIL or frank malignancy were seen in the smear).
Data Management and Analysis
The data was double entered in epi data version 126.96.36.199. and analyzed using Stata version 12. Descriptive statistics is presented as mean, frequency and percentage. Chi square test and fisher test were used to assess the statistical association keeping a p-value of <0.05 as statistically significant.
The ethical clearance was taken from the Research Ethics Board of Health (REBH) of Ministry of Health, Bhutan. Since, this is a retrospective study and doesn’t involve direct interaction with the participants, waiver for written inform consent was sought from the REBH. Patient confidentiality was maintained by removing all personal identifiers and assigning a unique code on the pro-forma, which was kept under lock and key. The electronic data files are protected by computer by use of password and shared only with the study team members.
During the study period, 1993 women availed Pap smears from the cytology units of Samtse Districts. The mean age was 37.9 years. The majority of women (62%) were in the age group below 39 years. Socio-demographic characteristics are presented in Table 1. Over half (56.65%) of the participants were housewives by occupation and majority (87.51%) of them were sexually active. Ninety three percent of the participants have ever had one sexual partner and 43% of them did not use contraception.
|Sexual partner ever had (n:1984)|
History of marriage and pregnancies is presented in Table 2. Most (92.22%) of the participants were currently married and around 10% of have been married more than once. Around 7% of them were married before they attained 15 years of age and 16% of them had their first pregnancy before the age of 18 years.
|No. of marriages (n: 1973)|
|Age at first marriage (n:1975)|
|No of marriages of husband (1940)|
|No of pregnancies|
|Age at 1st pregnancy|
|Last delivery/abortion (year) (n=1640)|
Almost all (98.90%) the participants did not have past history of sexually transmitted infections (STI) and around one-third of them had undergone a previous Pap-smear test (Table 3).
|Past history of STD|
|Previous Pap smear test|
|Past history of Inter-menstrual bleeding|
|Past history of post-coital bleeding|
|Past history of contact bleeding|
|Past history of cervical erosion|
|lower abdominal pain present||17||0.9|
|Pap smear type|
Around 6% had past history of inter-menstrual bleeding and 4% had history of cervical erosion. The majority (97.49%) of the slides were normal. 18 (0.9%) of patients had ASCUS and 9 (0.45%) had HSIL. Of the total number of smears taken, 2.5% (47) were found to be abnormal. Two patients aged more than 45 years also had squamous cell carcinoma.
In bivariate analysis using chi square and fisher exact test (Table 4), the abnormal Pap smear was significantly associated with marital status and age (p-value < 0.05).
|Variables||Normal smear||Abnormal smear||p-value|
|Govt/corporations/ armed forces||177||9.1||6||12.8|
|Number of marriages|
|No of marriages of husband|
|No of pregnancies|
|Age at 1st pregnancy (n=1895)|
|Not active at all||4||0.21||0||0||0.155**|
|Sexual partner ever had|
|Age at first marriage (years)|
|Previous Pap smear|
|Last delivery/abortion (year)|
This study presents the first data on the performance of Pap smear in a large district of Bhutan which has the potential to be representative of the country. In this study, the slide abnormality rate of Pap smear in Samtse District was 2.5% in 2018. This is comparable to a study in Turkey  where the slide abnormality rate was 2.5% and 4.7% . However, this is much lower than a study in India, where slide abnormality was as high as 72.5% . In another study in India, the cell abnormality rate was 10.8% . These differences among countries and regions could be due to difference in culture, race , HPV prevalence and sexual behaviors among this countries. Although, Bhutan is generally open society with more than half the population engaged with multiple sexual partners , the abnormal Pap smear is still low. This could be due to use of condom outside one’s marriage. An important contribution to these differences could be the expertise of the technicians screening the smears in microscopy. All smears in this study were screened by technicians and not qualified Pathologists. Although these are trained cyto-technicans, their limited expertise may result in misinterpretations. However, in such a scenario it is more likely to have more abnormal findings since technicians would probably grade doubtful slides as abnormal rather than normal. The most common abnormality in this study was ASCUS. This was a similar finding in other studies as well [16-21].
The majority of those availing the services in our study were women in the reproductive age groups. This could be due to better awareness on Pap smear services among younger women who are sexually active. The women in reproductive age groups are usually better informed about such screening services due to recurrent exposures to health workers during the time of antenatal, post-natal services and family planning services. This trend is similar in other countries as well . Housewives received Pap smear screening compared to other occupational groups. This was a similar finding in the capital city of Thimphu as well . The main reason could be due to the availability to time for these housewives to avail the services than those with permanent employment.
In this study, the abnormal Pap smear was significantly associated with the married women. HPV is responsible for majority of cervical cancer and it is sexually transmitted . Multiple studies in other countries have shown that multiple Pap smear is protective of cervical cancer. The pre-malignant lesions take years to become malignant lesion. Moreover, Pap smear which is the most common screening test used in developing countries has sensitivity of only 55.7% due to which a single test may not be able to detect the malignant lesions .
In this study, two patients had developed squamous cell carcinoma who were both older than 45 years. One of these patients never had Pap smear done and was detected when she presented with bleeding per vaginal. The most common symptoms of cervical cancer is bleeding per vaginal .
The use of condom prevents transmission of sexually transmitted infections due to which the incidences of abnormal Pap smear decreases [25-26]. However, in this study there was no difference in Pap smear among users and non-users of condom. The difference in result could be due to the setting of the questions in the form. The use of contraception in our data indicates the use of barrier method at the time of Pap smear screening.
The risk factors for cervical cancer include (but not limited to) sexually transmitted infections (HPV, chlamydia trachomatis and HIV), multiple sexual partners, high parity, OCP use, obesity and smoking [27-29]. Studies have shown that regular screening in women decreases cervical cancer by 67% . A systematic review showed that screening for cervical cancer by any method is associated with decreased incidence and death from cervical cancer . The mortality associated with cervical cancer can be prevented by timely access to comprehensive cervical cancer prevention and control program which advocates for HPV vaccination for girls and screening and treatment for pre-cancerous lesion . Since Bhutan has embarked on the elimination of the cervical cancer during the 144th session of WHO executive board at Geneva , the provision of quality and timely results for Pop smear needs to be strengthened Unlike most cancers, the elimination of cervical cancer is doable since, it has a long latent period. Therefore, the Pap smear screening at earlier age can detect pre-malignant lesions and can be treated appropriately before it becomes malignant. However, the older women should not be neglected as high prevalence of abnormal cytology in Pap smear has also been observed in older women too .
This further reiterates the need for equitable continued Pap smear screening both young and old women.
This study has its own limitations. Since this was a retrospective study, other factors which could affect the Pap smear report like education and income couldn’t be accessed. Moreover, the Pap smear services are offered passive screening whereby women with abnormal smears may not have come forward for screening services. Other risk factors like intake of alcohol and tobacco was not accessed in this study.
In conclusion, the study found that slide abnormality rate of 2.5% in Samtse District. The abnormality is more common among married and older women. Therefore,additional screening efforts needs to be more prioritized on this group to detect pre-malignant lesions. Since Bhutan has embarked for elimination of cervical cancer,additional screening camps needs to be carried out to reach the unreached. And the health assistants in the BHU needs to be properly trained and motivated to achieve this goal.
Declaration of interest
There is no conflict of interest involved for this study.
There is no budget involved in this study.
All the authors contributed equally for the conception,drafting, analysis and finalization of the manuscript.
- World Health Organization Cervical Cancer 2019 [Available from: https://www.who.int/cancer/prevention/diagnosis-screening/cervical-cancer/en/..
- World Health Organization Human papillomavirus (HPV) and cervical cancer 2019 [Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/human-papillomavirus-(hpv)-and-cervical-cancer..
- Eliminate cervical cancer? We can do it 2019 [Available from: http://www.searo.who.int/mediacentre/features/2019/eliminate-cervical-cancer-we-can-do-it/en/ Singh PK. .
- World Health Organization Strategic framework for the Comprehensive Control of Cancer Cervix in South-East Asia Region. 2015..
- New technologies for cervical cancer screening Brown Alaina J., Trimble Cornelia L.. Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology.2012;26(2). CrossRef
- Pap Smear: Medscape; 2018 [Available from: https://emedicine.medscape.com/article/1947979-overview#showall Karjane NW. .
- Recommendations for screening and early detection of common cancers in India Rajaraman Preetha, Anderson Benjamin O, Basu Partha, Belinson Jerome L, Cruz Anil D', Dhillon Preet K, Gupta Prakash, Jawahar Tenkasi S, Joshi Niranjan, Kailash Uma, Kapambwe Sharon, Katoch Vishwa Mohan, Krishnan Suneeta, Panda Dharitri, Sankaranarayanan R, Selvam Jerard M, Shah Keerti V, Shastri Surendra, Shridhar Krithiga, Siddiqi Maqsood, Sivaram Sudha, Seth Tulika, Srivastava Anurag, Trimble Edward, Mehrotra Ravi. The Lancet Oncology.2015;16(7). CrossRef
- World Health Organization Comprehensive Cervical Cancer Control A guide to essential practice Second edition. 2014..
- World Health Organization Cervical cancer, human papillomavirus (HPV), and HPV vaccines :Key points for policy-makers and health professionals 2007 [Available from: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/69873/WHO_RHR_08.14_eng.pdf?sequence=1..
- International Agency for Research on Cancer Cancer today 2018 [Available from: https://gco.iarc.fr/today/online-analysis-map?v=2018&mode=population&mode_population=continents&population=900&populations=900&key=asr&sex=0&cancer=39&type=0&statistic=5&prevalence=0&population_group=0&ages_group%5B%5D=0&ages_group%5B%5D=17&nb_items=5&group_cancer=1&include_nmsc=1&include_nmsc_other=1&projection=natural-earth&color_palette=default&map_scale=quantile&map_nb_colors=5&continent=0&rotate=%255B10%252C0%255D..
- ICO (Institut Català d'Oncologia) Information Centre. Bhutan Human Papillomavirus and Related Cancers, Fact Sheet 2018 2019 [Available from: https://hpvcentre.net/statistics/reports/BTN_FS.pdf..
- Bhutan commits to eliminate cervical cancer Tshomo D. 2019 .
- Ministry of Health Cervical Cancer Screening Guideline. 2014 [Available from: http://www.health.gov.bt/wp-content/uploads/ict-files/2014/11/Cervical-Cancer-screening-manual-2014.pdf..
- National Statistical Bereau Samtse at a glance, 2018.2019.
- Cervical Cancer Screening in an Early Diagnosis and Screening Center in Mersin, Turkey Nayir Tufan, Okyay Ramazan Azim, Nazlican Ersin, Yesilyurt Hakki, Akbaba Muhsin, Ilhan Berrin, Kemik Aytekin. Asian Pacific Journal of Cancer Prevention.2015;16(16). CrossRef
- Abnormal Pap-smear frequency and comparison of repeat cytological follow-up with colposcopy during patient management; The importance of pathologist's guidance in the management Arslan Erol. Northern Clinics of Istanbul.2018. CrossRef
- Study of cervical pap smears in a tertiary care hospital of south Gujarat, India Tailor Hemali, R.D. Patel, Patel Prashant, Bhagat Vasudha. International Journal of Research in Medical Sciences.2016. CrossRef
- Clinicopathological correlation of pap smear findings in gynecological cases: A retrospective Study Singh K, Singh A. IJSR NET available online at: www ijsr net/archive/v4i7/SUB156747 pdf. 2015..
- Racial disparities in cervical cancer: Worse than we thought Dalton Heather J., Farley John H.. Cancer.2017;123(6). CrossRef
- Predictors of multiple sexual partnerships among women and men in two urban townships in Bhutan Dorji G, Umeh C, Ramesh B, Isac S, Lorway R, Blanchard J. Bhutan Health Journal.2016;2(1):18-24.
- Study of cervical pap smears in a tertiary hospital Bamanikar SA, Baravkar DS, Chandanwale SS, Dapkekar P. Indian Medical Gazette.2014;148(7):250-254.
- Papanicolaou Test Use Among Reproductive-Age Women at High Risk for Cervical Cancer: Analyses of the 1995 National Survey of Family Growth Hewitt Maria, Devesa Susan, Breen Nancy. American Journal of Public Health.2002;92(4). CrossRef
- Cervical cancer screening program in Thimphu, Bhutan: population coverage and characteristics associated with screening attendance Baussano Iacopo, Tshomo Ugyen, Clifford Gary M, Tenet Vanessa, Tshokey Tshokey, Franceschi Silvia. BMC Women's Health.2014;14(1). CrossRef
- Delayed diagnosis of cervical cancer in young women Yu CK, Chiu C, McCormack M, Olaitan A. Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology.2005;25(4). CrossRef
- Incidence and risk factors of abnormal cervical cytology in a university hospital - Saudi Arabia El. Mahalli AzzaAli. Saudi Journal for Health Sciences.2015;4(2). CrossRef
- Condom use promotes regression of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia and clearance of human papillomavirus: A randomized clinical trial Hogewoning Cornelis J.A., Bleeker Maaike C.G., van den Brule Adriaan J.C., Voorhorst Feja J., Snijders Peter J.F., Berkhof Johannes, Westenend Pieter J., Meijer Chris J.L.M.. International Journal of Cancer.2003;107(5). CrossRef
- Incidence, mortality and risk factors of cervical cancer in the world Momenimovahed Zohre, Salehiniya Hamid. Biomedical Research and Therapy.2017;4(12). CrossRef
- Risk Factors for Cervical Cancer in Thailand: a Case-Control Study Chichareon Saibua, Herrero Rolando, Muñoz Nubia, Bosch F. Xavier, Jacobs Marcel V., Deacon Judith, Santamaria Mercedes, Chongsuvivatwong Virasakdi, Meijer Chris J. L. M., Walboomers Jan M. M.. JNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute.1998;90(1). CrossRef
- Multiple Sexual Partners as a Potential Independent Risk Factor for Cervical Cancer: a Meta-analysis of Epidemiological Studies Liu Zhi-Chang, Liu Wei-Dong, Liu Yan-Hui, Ye Xiao-Hua, Chen Si-Dong. Asian Pacific Journal of Cancer Prevention.2015;16(9). CrossRef
- Impact of cervical screening on cervical cancer mortality: estimation using stage-specific results from a nested case–control study Landy Rebecca, Pesola Francesca, Castañón Alejandra, Sasieni Peter. British Journal of Cancer.2016;115(9). CrossRef
- Screening for cervical cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis Peirson Leslea, Fitzpatrick-Lewis Donna, Ciliska Donna, Warren Rachel. Systematic Reviews.2013;2(1). CrossRef
- World Health Organization World Health Day 2019 - Gasa Dzongkhag 2019 [Available from: http://www.searo.who.int/bhutan/whd-2019/en/..
- Age and pattern of Pap smear abnormalities: Implications for cervical cancer control in a developing country Olusegun AjenifujaKayode, Akinfolarin AdepitiClement, Omoladun Okunola, Omoniyi-Esan GO, Onwundiegu Uche. Journal of Cytology.2017;34(4). CrossRef
- Abstract viewed - 369 times
- PDF (FULL TEXT) downloaded - 211 times
- XML downloaded - 62 times